Passkeys Explained and When to Drop Your Password
Your phone or browser has probably asked whether you want to save a passkey, and you probably said not now. Most people do.

Your phone or browser has probably asked whether you want to save a passkey, and you probably said not now. Most people do. The prompt arrives mid login, it uses a word nobody explained, and saying yes feels like agreeing to something you cannot undo.
It is worth ten minutes of your attention, because a passkey closes the one hole that a strong password and a text message code leave wide open. A convincing fake login page can still take your password and your six digit code and use both within seconds. It cannot take a passkey, and that difference is the whole reason the technology exists.
What a passkey actually is
When you create a passkey, your device generates two matching keys. The private one stays on your phone, laptop or in your password manager and never leaves. The public one goes to the website, which stores it. Signing in means the site sends a challenge, your device signs it with the private key, and the site checks the signature against the public key it already holds.
Three consequences follow from that, and they are the only technical details you need.
There is no shared secret on the server. A site that gets breached leaks public keys, which are useless on their own. Compare that with a password database, where even hashed passwords can be attacked offline for months.
The passkey is locked to one web address. Your device records the exact domain when the passkey is created and will refuse to offer it to anything else. A fake page at a lookalike address simply does not get the option presented, which is why phishing a passkey does not work in the way phishing a code does.
Your fingerprint or face is not sent anywhere. The biometric check happens on your own hardware and only unlocks the key sitting there. The site never receives it, and never has.
In practice signing in looks like this: you tap your email address, your phone asks for your face or fingerprint, and you are in. No password field, no code to copy, usually under three seconds.
Why this beats a password plus a text code
Two factor authentication is still the best upgrade most people can make, and nothing here argues against it. But the attack that gets past it is now cheap and widespread, and it is worth understanding what it does.
The technique is a relay. You click a link in an email, land on a page that looks exactly like your bank or your email provider, and type your password. The page passes it straight to the real site in real time. The real site asks for your code, the fake page asks you for the same code, you type it, and the fake page forwards it. The attacker now holds the session cookie that the real site issued, which means they are logged in as you and your second factor did its job perfectly against nothing at all. Ready made kits for this have been sold for a few hundred dollars a month for several years.
A passkey breaks the relay at the first step. The fake domain is not the domain the passkey was registered to, so the browser never offers it and there is nothing for you to hand over by mistake. You cannot be talked into using a passkey on the wrong site, which is the useful part, because being talked into things is how almost all of this happens.
The other quiet benefit is that a passkey already contains two factors: something you have, the device holding the private key, and something you are or know, the biometric or PIN that unlocks it. That is why many sites stop asking for a separate code once a passkey is in place.
Where to turn them on first
Do not try to convert everything. Start with the accounts that can be used to reset other accounts, and work down. Each of these takes about a minute, and the setting is nearly always under security in your account settings.
- Your main email. Whoever controls your inbox can reset most of your other logins, which makes it the account worth protecting first. Google, Microsoft and Apple accounts all support passkeys now.
- Your password manager. If it offers a passkey for the account login, use it. The vault still has its own master password, and that stays separate, as our note on reusing a password manager master password explains.
- Anything with money attached. PayPal, Amazon and eBay have supported passkeys for a while. Banks are slower and many still offer nothing, so check rather than assume.
- Accounts tied to your identity or work. GitHub, LinkedIn, and your employer's single sign on if they allow it. These are where targeted attacks land first.
- Set up a second passkey on a different device before you consider the job done. One on your phone and one on your laptop, or one in a cross platform password manager that syncs. A single passkey on a single phone is a lockout waiting to happen.
- Write down where each passkey lives. A line in a note is enough. In a year you will not remember whether a given account uses the one in your browser, the one on your phone, or both.
If your phone and laptop are different ecosystems, the sign in flow on an unfamiliar computer uses a QR code: the site shows one, you scan it with your phone, and the two confirm proximity over Bluetooth. It feels odd the first time and takes about fifteen seconds. Bluetooth has to be on for it, which catches people out on desktop machines.
What the enthusiasm leaves out
You will read that passwords are finished and you can delete them. I would not, and there are three real limits worth knowing before you commit.
The first is account recovery, which is where the actual weakness now sits. A site may protect logins with an unphishable passkey and still let someone reset the whole account with a link sent to an email address, or a call to a support agent. The strongest front door does not help if the side gate opens to a convincing phone call. Until providers tighten recovery, a passkey raises the cost of attacking you without making you immune, so keep your recovery email itself locked down and treat any unexpected reset message as hostile. The habits in our guide to spotting a phishing link still apply to every one of those messages.
The second is portability. A passkey created in Apple's keychain syncs across Apple devices, one created in Google's manager syncs across Google ones, and moving them between ecosystems has only recently started to become possible. Export and import between managers is arriving but is not something to rely on yet. Creating your important passkeys inside a cross platform password manager avoids the problem at the cost of trusting that manager with more.
The third is coverage. Support is good among large technology companies and patchy everywhere else, and a fair number of sites that offer a passkey keep the old password active alongside it, which means the password remains an attack route whether you use it or not. On those accounts a passkey improves your daily experience more than your security. That is still worth having, but it is not the same claim.
So the sensible position for the next year or two: add passkeys wherever they are offered, keep a long unique password in your manager as the fallback, and keep an authenticator app set up for the accounts that still need codes. Our walkthrough of setting up two factor authentication covers that side, and the rest of the security section has the groundwork.
FAQ
What happens if I lose the phone with my passkeys on it?
If your passkeys sync through your Apple, Google or password manager account, they are already on your other devices and on any new phone you sign into. If a passkey was created as device bound, for example on a hardware security key, it is gone with the device and you fall back to the account's recovery method. This is the reason to set up a second passkey somewhere else early.
Can someone unlock my passkey with my fingerprint while I am asleep?
Physically possible, which is why the threat model matters more than the technology. Face unlock on current iPhones and Pixels requires open eyes and attention. If you are worried about someone with physical access to you and your phone, the useful step is a strong screen lock and a review of what is already installed on the device, since that threat is not one any login method can solve.
Do passkeys work without an internet connection?
The key itself works offline, but the site you are signing into obviously needs to be reachable. Cross device sign in needs Bluetooth between your phone and the computer rather than internet on both, which is why it still works on a hotel computer with a flaky connection.
Should I delete my password once a passkey works?
Only if the site lets you remove it entirely and you have at least two working passkeys on separate devices. Most sites currently keep the password whether you want them to or not. Where you cannot delete it, change it to something long and random in your password manager and never type it again.
More in Security
Security
How to Audit Browser Extensions Before They Leak Data
A reader wrote to me in March about a screenshot tool he had used for four years.
Security
How to Check Your Phone for Spyware and Stalkerware
Someone seems to know where you have been, or what you said in a private message, and you cannot work out how.
Security
Is Public Phone Charging Safe and How to Avoid Juice Jacking
Your phone is at 6 percent, the gate changed, and there is a row of free USB ports right next to your seat.