How to Choose a Printer Without Paying for Ink Forever
A friend called me last spring because her printer had stopped working. It had not stopped working. It had run out of ink, and the replacement set for her 59 dollar all-in-one cost 68 dollars.

A friend called me last spring because her printer had stopped working. It had not stopped working. It had run out of ink, and the replacement set for her 59 dollar all-in-one cost 68 dollars. She had owned the machine for five months and printed maybe 240 pages, mostly school forms and shipping labels.
Printers are the clearest example of hardware sold below cost so the consumables can earn the money back. That is not a scandal, it is just the business model, and it means the sticker price tells you almost nothing about what the machine will cost you. The number that matters is cost per page, and you can work it out from a product listing in about five minutes.
Why the cheap printer is usually the expensive one
Two things make entry level inkjets costly to own. The first is cartridge capacity. A standard colour cartridge for a budget machine holds a surprisingly small amount of ink, often rated for 165 to 200 pages at 5 percent coverage, which is the industry test pattern and far lighter than a real page of text. The second is the starter cartridge. The set in the box is frequently half filled, rated for 100 to 150 pages, so the first refill arrives sooner than anyone expects.
There is also the maintenance ink nobody counts. Inkjets run a cleaning cycle on power-up and on a schedule, flushing ink through the nozzles into a sponge or a waste tank. On a printer used twice a month, a meaningful share of every cartridge goes into that sponge rather than onto paper. This is the main reason occasional users feel like the ink evaporates.
So the question to answer before anything else is not which brand, but how many pages per month you print, and how many of those need colour. Everything else follows from those two numbers. Our broader look at the hidden costs hiding in cheap tech covers the same trap in other categories.
The four printer types and what a page costs
These figures are the ranges I see when I divide cartridge or bottle prices by the manufacturer's own page ratings. Treat them as order of magnitude rather than gospel, because cartridge prices move.
| Type | Hardware price | Mono page | Colour page | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cartridge inkjet, entry | 50 to 110 dollars | 7 to 12 cents | 20 to 30 cents | Under 20 pages a month, if anything |
| Ink tank inkjet | 200 to 400 dollars | 0.3 to 0.6 cents | 1 to 3 cents | Families, photos, mixed colour use |
| Mono laser | 120 to 200 dollars | 2 to 4 cents | Not available | Text only, 50 to 500 pages a month |
| Colour laser | 280 to 500 dollars | 3 to 5 cents | 12 to 18 cents | Small offices printing reports |
The ink tank column is the one that surprises people. Those printers ship with bottles rather than cartridges, and a single 70 ml black bottle costing 13 to 19 dollars is rated for somewhere around 6,000 to 7,500 pages. The machine costs three or four times as much up front and then stops costing you anything much. On roughly 100 pages a month with a quarter in colour, an ink tank model pays back its extra purchase price in about two years against a cheap cartridge inkjet, and after that the gap widens every month.
Laser consumables need one extra check. Toner is cheap per page, but colour lasers also use a drum or imaging unit that wears out separately, typically rated for 12,000 to 20,000 pages and priced at 60 to 130 dollars. Transfer belts and waste toner boxes exist on some models too. Find those parts on the manufacturer's accessory page before you buy, because a cheap colour laser with expensive drums is the laser version of the same trick.
The advice I push back on: just get a laser
Ask on any forum and you will be told that inkjets always clog, so buy a laser and never think about it again. For someone printing letters, invoices and the occasional PDF, that is sound. For a lot of households it is the wrong recommendation, and I have watched it play out badly.
Colour laser output on plain paper is fine for charts and poor for anything photographic. The toner sits on the surface, so skin tones go flat and dark areas band. If your colour printing is school projects, craft work or photos for a frame, a laser will disappoint you no matter what you spend. Lasers also pull 600 to 1,200 watts during the fuser warm-up, take 8 to 15 seconds before the first page, and are heavier and bulkier than most people picture.
The clogging argument is also really an argument about usage frequency. Inkjets clog when they sit idle for weeks, and ink tank models with pigment black are noticeably more tolerant than old cartridge machines, but none of them like being ignored. If you genuinely print once every two months, buy a mono laser, or skip owning a printer and use a print shop. Between those extremes, print something in colour once a fortnight and an inkjet stays healthy. I set a recurring calendar reminder for this on two machines in my own house, which feels silly and has saved a print head.
Subscriptions, firmware and the network side
Ink subscription plans charge a monthly fee for a page allowance, with cartridges posted to you automatically. For a predictable 50 to 100 pages a month they can genuinely cost less than buying cartridges at retail. Read three things first: how many unused pages roll over and for how long, what a page over the allowance costs, and what happens if you cancel. On some plans the cartridges are metered and stop printing when the subscription ends, even with ink inside them. That last detail is the one people find out at the worst moment.
Firmware deserves attention for a similar reason. Manufacturers have shipped updates that stop third party and refilled cartridges from working. If saving money on compatible cartridges is part of your plan, turn off automatic firmware updates after setup, and accept that you are also turning off security fixes.
That trade-off matters because a printer is a small networked computer with a web interface, and people forget it exists. Mine sat for two years with the default blank admin password. A few habits are worth the ten minutes they take.
- Set an admin password on the printer's built-in web page during setup.
- Turn off services you do not use, especially cloud print, email-to-print and remote management.
- Keep it on your main network, not open to the internet. If you have ever forwarded a port to a printer, undo that.
- Clear stored scans and fax logs before you sell or recycle the machine, since many all-in-ones keep an internal copy.
Matching the machine to the house
For a household printing under 20 pages a month, almost all text, a mono laser at 130 dollars with a 1,500 page toner cartridge is the cheapest honest answer. For a family at 80 to 150 pages a month with school work and photos, an ink tank all-in-one at 250 to 350 dollars will be the last printer you buy for a long time. For a two or three person office producing colour reports, a colour laser with a duplex unit and a published drum price earns its keep.
Whatever you pick, buy one duplicate set of consumables at the same time and note the model number inside a cupboard door. Running out of a cartridge you cannot name at 11pm is how people end up paying retail panic prices. The same thinking in our guide to buying tech without overpaying applies here, and the rest of the buying guides go category by category.
FAQ
Are ink tank printers worth the higher price?
If you print more than about 40 pages a month, yes. The extra 150 to 250 dollars up front is usually recovered within two years, and the saving continues afterwards.
Is a laser printer cheaper than an inkjet?
Per text page, almost always. Per colour page, no. A mono laser also cannot print photos acceptably, so the answer depends entirely on what you print.
Do third party cartridges damage a printer?
Good ones rarely do, though a leaking cartridge can make a mess and a failure may not be covered under warranty. The bigger risk is a firmware update blocking them later.
How often should I use an inkjet printer?
Print at least one colour page every two weeks. That keeps ink moving through the nozzles and avoids the cleaning cycles that drain cartridges on neglected machines.
More in Buying Guides
Buying Guides
How to Choose a Soundbar Without Paying for Fake Channels
I bought a soundbar in 2023 that said 5.1.2 on the box for 249 dollars.
Buying Guides
How to Choose a Laptop for College Without Overspending
Buying a laptop for college usually happens in a rush in late summer, with a store employee pointing at a 1,400 dollar machine...
Buying Guides
How to Choose a WiFi Router Without Paying for Hype
Your WiFi drops in the back bedroom, video calls freeze at the worst moment, and the router box in the shop promises "up to...